Publications: Speakers Corner


Recovery of Costs in Service Charge Disputes

This article considers in what circumstances costs in service charge disputes in the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber)1 (“the Tribunal”) can be recovered. The Tribunal’s powers Rule 13 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Property Chamber) Rules 2013 introduced a new rule on orders for costs, reimbursement of fees and interest on costs. The rule provides […]

1st Feb 2014 Speakers Corner Read more

Terminal dilapidations – checklist

1. First start with considering extent of liability to repair under the Lease. What are the precise terms of the repairing, decorating, alterations, yielding up, statutory compliance covenants. What was the length of Lease and what is the age and nature of the Premises? Is there any Schedule of Condition or exclusion of inherent defects. […]

16th Aug 2013 Speakers Corner Read more

Accommodating Rights of Way

The problem Packemin Apartments Limited (“PA”) acquires a plot of prime development land for the construction of a block of luxury flats. Unfortunately, the land in question (“Plot A”) has no direct access to the main public highway. In order to obtain the required access to this public highway PA has to obtain the grant […]

1st Jun 2013 Speakers Corner Read more

Party Wall Appeals – lessons from the Rolls Building case

Introduction Section 10 of the Party Wall etc. Act 1996 (‘the Act’) provides a now well-known and established mechanism for resolving disputes between building owners and adjoining owners in respect of matters concerned with works to which the Act relates, that is principally building on the line of the junction between different lands (s.1), the […]

22nd May 2013 Speakers Corner Read more

Freetown v Assethold

Service by post re-visited: Freetwon V Assethold Several property statutes contain a provision enabling a notice (or some other document) to be served by being “sent by post” (without prescribing any particular method of posting): see section 176(2) and (3) of the Housing Act 1985; section 54(2) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987; section […]

5th Feb 2013 Speakers Corner Read more

Assessment of damages for professional negligence

Transaction or no transaction? That is the question How damages for professional negligence are often assessed in the context of residential and commercial conveyancing. It has been said that the assessment of damages for professional negligence is more of an art than a science. Nowhere is this more true than in the context of residential […]

1st Jan 2013 Speakers Corner Read more

Edwards & Walkden v City of London, changing terms or approach?

Is the case of Edwards & Walkden v City of London consistent with the O’May decision in relation to changing terms of business tenancies on renewal or does it evidence a change in the approach of the Court? Introduction On 21.09.2012 Mr Justice Sales gave judgment in the trial of two preliminary issues in the […]

30th Nov 2012 Speakers Corner Read more

Ground (d): An Unsuitable Ploy?

Context Where there is a tenancy to which part II of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 and the procedural requirements of sections 25 or 26 of that Act have been fulfilled, the statute imposes an obligation on the Court to grant a new tenancy save in very limited circumstances. Under section 24(1): “A tenancy […]

1st Jan 2012 Speakers Corner Read more

On the house S.2(1) of the Leasehold Reform Act 1967 after Hosebay & Magnohard

Introduction 1. The definition of “house” in s.2(1) of the Leasehold Reform Act 1967 has given rise to considerable difficulties in the 45 years since it was enacted. This year, there have been two further appellate decisions on the definition – Hosebay v Day [2012] 1 WLR 2884 in the Supreme Court (where Lord Carnwath […]

1st Jan 2012 Speakers Corner Read more

PLA Dilapidations Protocol supported by surveyors, but they’re still revolting

At their recent annual conference, the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) Dilapidations Forum delegates soundly rejected any suggestion that the PLA Protocol should be scrapped. Inevitably though there are calls for the detail of the document to be revised (dilapidations surveyors are nothing if not persistent when it comes to finding disagreement!). It is […]

1st Jan 2009 Speakers Corner Read more