On 27 October, a packed room of JPLA members gathered for a much-anticipated evening with Upper Tribunal Judge Elizabeth Cooke. The discussion ranged from her journey to the Bench and practical insights for Tribunal practitioners to courtroom ‘horror stories’ - timely with Hallowe’en approaching - and what the future might hold.
Reflecting on her work in academia and at the Law Commission of England and Wales, Judge Cooke offered an insight into her route to judicial office and the different perspective that comes with deciding cases rather than presenting them.
Her case examples prompted useful reminders about managing client expectations, scrutinising the assumptions underpinning expert evidence and experts’ duty to assist the Tribunal independently. The discussion also explored occasions when separating issues for trial can be the most effective way forward.
Questions from the audience turned to AI, prompting discussion of both its potential uses and the risks of poor-quality material reaching the Tribunal. A key theme was the continuing responsibility of those submitting material, whatever tools they use to prepare it. The discussion also considered the potential for technology to assist with more formulaic work, alongside the importance to parties of having their cases heard by a human judge.
A particularly strong message was Judge Cooke’s encouragement to practitioners to consider judicial office. For those genuinely interested in exploring that avenue, she recommended shadowing a judge, reflecting on the value of her own experience. While acknowledging the practical challenges, she offered an encouraging perspective on judicial life. Her invitation was clear: give the possibility serious thought and find out more.
Practitioners interested in exploring judicial office can find further information through the Judicial Appointments Commission.
Our sincere thanks go to Upper Tribunal Judge Elizabeth Cooke for giving her time so generously and sharing her insight, and to Pinsent Masons for being such wonderful hosts.